Complete with campaign maps, commandstructure charts, and lists of major german military leaders, why the germans lose at war combines brilliant military and political analysis with a powerful cautionary tale for any nation that seeks to rule the world through force alone. Kenneth macksey the german armed forces suffered crushing defeat in the last century. The german army of ww2 was mostly a conscript army. The myth of german military superiority by kenneth. Were they the random fortunes of war, or the inevitable result of a particular structure. It got to the point that there was a tank scandal in the media at the end of 19441945, and the army s leadership, not having enough on their plate trying to win the actual war, started having to devote time to win the. Or, alternatively, if you compare just the german fighter force against the british fighter force, again, the german superiority. Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples log in dictionary. He debunks the vast superiority of the german army, revealing that the more experienced french troops did well in battle against the germans. From their point of view, after all, with the army came the.
Instead, gamelin settled for a defensive war of attrition believing that the french had superior resources and were well prepared. Their wehrmacht was better than our army washington post. Germanic religion and mythology, complex of stories, lore, and beliefs about the gods and the nature of the cosmos developed by the germanicspeaking peoples before their conversion to christianity. Army budget is the total military establishment expenditures portion of the total war department expenditurescivil expenditures make up the difference. The africa core was held at tobruk but monty did not attack until. The german military performance on the russian front during the second world war. Why germans lose at war myth of german military superiority.
The first myth is the myth of the us military superiority. Sometime around 1700 bce, the aryans invaded the ancient urban civilizations of the indus valley and destroyed their culture. The numbers say it all the myth of german superiority on. Polish army in wwii it tried to field cavalry against german tanks and it did not end well, he said. Union, aimed at gaining german dominance of eastern europe. Dunkirk, the patriotic myth, nicholas harman, jun 16, 1980. Both myths glorify the confederate military and the wehrmacht as superior fighting organizations led by deeply honorable, noble and courageous. Speer, goering, keitel, jodl, doenitz, allied airpower was the decisive factor in the germans losing the war. Military superiority definition and meaning collins. German military fact and fiction armored warfare official website. What are the origins of the effective wehrmacht myth. Why the germans lose at war, myth of german military.
It denied the german military air superiority over the english channel, making a seaborne invasion planned as operation sea lion impossible in the face of britains naval power. Mackey is a cut above most of the military historians ive read in terms of writing style. Part iv of the analysis of fighting power on the eastern front, during the battle of kursk and in 1944. When you crunch the numbers, it turns out that russian superiority was not so great as is commonly believed. Total of 240 pages with lots of information and pictures. Training of soldiers, casualties, awards and death sentences of german and us army during the second world war. According to many of the top nazi and german military leaders. We look into the burning at least for some question of whether members of the national german socialist workers party were accurately classified as. The threat of sealion was bigger than its actual execution. I just fervently hope that the people of the usa will not find out how mistaken they are the hard way. When i was younger i was sure that the germans in wwii had a superior military and the most technologically advanced weapons, aircraft and equipment. This difference appears in the middle of 1943, after the soviet army had two years of wartime experience, was using experienced units, and had time to rest, train, and rebuild before the german offensive. Possibly the most common and prevalent myth concerns the training superiority of the germans, specifically the waffen ss units. The myth of german military superiority by kenneth macksey from boffins books in perth, australia.
Those who werent conscripts were retards who believed their blonde hair and blue eyes made them bullet proof. What is the origin of the german ww2 tank superiority myth. Or, alternatively, if you compare just the german fighter force against the british fighter force, again, the german superiority is only marginal. Some 1,200 years after the supposed invasion, the descendants of. I assume this is mainly asking about the soft aspects of the german military that allowed it outperform its peers.
Ww2 started in september 1939 with the invasion of poland. Control of the air is the aerial equivalent of command of the sea air power has increasingly become a powerful element of military campaigns. From what ive read, i would say around the end of the battle of stalingrad. Allied air power was decisive factor in western europe. The lost cause and the myth of southern martial superiority.
Running counter to that perception, before the war was even a year. Pdf the myth of nations download full pdf book download. Technological and military superiority of nazi germany. Debunking two american myths the vineyard of the saker. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. Wehrmacht vs us army fighting power of the wehrmacht, part ii. Germanic culture extended, at various times, from the black sea to greenland, or even the north american continent. No, polish cavalry never attacked nazi tanks, irate poland tells mad money host.
The red army did attain numerical superiority on the eastern front. For almost a decade after 1933, hitler enjoyed a remarkable degree of popularity among the great majority of the german people. Its an enduring myth born from another myth of overall german efficiency, which itself is rooted in ideas born of nationalism, religion and enlightenment era thought. Feb 12, 2010 germany s numerical strength over the raf during the battle of britain was only marginal, once you take the whole raf into account and not just fighter command. Kenneth macksey more than 60 years after their utter defeat and surrender, the nazi army, navy, and air force are still remembered as the best organized, best trained, best equipped, and most formidable fighting. The luftwaffes experiences in the spanish civil war are examined.
The myth of german military superiority greenhill military paperback at. Nazism and the myth of the masterrace world socialist. This is a used condition soft cover book, why germans lose at war myth of german military superiority reference book. It rarely demonstrated the steamroller superiority of german myth and hollywood hyperbole. The germans invented an allnew blitzkrieg doctrine. The germans, and the rest of the field in those four events owens dominated, would prove no match for the 22yearold from cleveland. Instead, gamelin settled for a defensive war of attrition believing that the french had superior resources. Kenneth macksey examines the reasons behind these catastrophic military failures. If in germany, and in some circles in the west, the myth of the professional wehrmacht was sustained long after the war, those most viciously persecuted by the nazis as the reichs political and biological enemies by and large identified the german soldier with hitlers regime. Blitzkrieg is almost never mentioned in any of the official german war manuals prior to the outbreak of war. The aim is to try and illuminate the deeper, underlying issues of nationalism that cause so much conflict throughout the world. Raugh and others published why the germans lose at war. Criticism by nigel askey of the myth of german superiority on the ww2 eastern front. Kenneth macksey now examines the reasons behind these catastrophic military failures.
The myth of the clean wehrmacht is the fictitious notion that the regular german armed forces the wehrmacht were not involved in the holocaust or other war crimes during world war ii. Download now in this volume, a group of specialists look at the general and theoretical nature of myth on a universal basis, and examine the specific myths of various nations. But not all of the official narrative is strictly based on the truth, such as the notion of german war superiority. And thats just one example of germans tactical and military superiority there are many others. This june, that unexceptional agility was on display when german pilots flew eurofighter typhoons successfully against f22s in mock dogfights. Comments like there were 10 soviets for every german are simply myths propagated by german archival information like the. What explains military superiority of germany during ww2. This paper can be downloaded without charge from the social science research network electronic. Demystifying the german armament miracle during world war ii. Strategically, the overall situation at home and abroad at the end of the battle might be considered air parity between britain and germany. It was one of britains most important victories of the second world war and prevented germany from invading britain. Buy a discounted paperback of why the germans lose at war online from australias leading online bookstore.
Over the years my reading, studies and military experience cast doubt on the truth of this perception. November 10, 2017 information clearing house there are two myths which are deeply imprinted in the minds of most us americans which are extremely dangerous and which can result in a war with russia. Air supremacy is a degree of air superiority where a side holds complete control of air warfare and air power over opposing forces. By the time the german forces had reached stalingrad they were already overstretched and the luftwaffe although still having air superiority suffered numerous losses numbering around half the. Soviet numerical advantages in world war ii were significant but not overwhelming. Nov 10, 2017 the combined effect of the myth of us military superiority with the myth about the us invulnerability result in a us american sense of detachment, or even impunity, which is not at all supported by fact. I agree dansanabbott, but not withstanding any slowing down of the rate of fire due to the sychronising gear operation, this small advantage of the twingun german fighters is quite different from the oftportrayed german firepower superiority displayed over. How donald trump inflames the culture war and why this is good news for america. Why the germans lose at war by kenneth macksey boffins books. May 02, 2017 the myth of soviet numerical superiority blitz of the reich. Myth in this sense a widely held but false belief or idea.
Criticism by nigel askey of the myth of german superiority. In the end, like most host nations, germany won a lot of medals, but the image of aryan superiority was punctured for the world to see. Although densethis being primarily a condensed survey of the european theatre of wwii with focus on the german officers who led itand slow going for one not already familiar with the principals, it became increasingly enjoyable as i became accustomed to his rhythms. The tannenberg myth in history and literature, 19141945. Britain was not small compared with germany when one takes in account the size of population, the industrial output, the level of military technology etc. These indus valley civilizations also known as harappa or sarasvati were far more civilized than any other horseback nomad, with a written language, farming capabilities, and a truly urban existence. No, polish cavalry never attacked nazi tanks, irate poland. The red army won only by weight of numbers a myth developed during and after the war, propagated by german generals whose memoirs explained their defeat by claiming that their professional and technical superiority were undone by the soviets swamping them with numbers. The myth denies the culpability of the german military command in the planning and preparation of war crimes. Another point i would like to point out that the myth of mechanization of german army. The myth of german military superiority macksey, kenneth on. And there was the royal navy if covered by spitfireshurricanes, it could make any german landing operation quite difficult. The myth of soviet numerical superiority blitz of the reich.
Author of military errors of world war two, kesselringsoftbound, why the germans lose at war. The myth of german military superiority as want to read. Allied air power was decisive factor in western europe by greg kopchuk. The myth of american military superiority discussion in americas started by banu umayyah, oct 19. Unless we have supermen in our army which i believe there are as i am a fan of our military, but oherwise it aint possible. This myth is built around the rules of engagement handed down to the military that said certain places couldnt be bombed and certain things couldnt be done and if the politicians hadnt made those rules and allowed free reign the united states would have easily. Jun 22, 2019 the german invasion of the soviet union, launched on 22 june 1941, was the largest military operation in history. Germany s numerical strength over the raf during the battle of britain was only marginal, once you take the whole raf into account and not just fighter command. German army was never wholly mechanized unlike the allied forces. Kenneth macksey the german armed forces have suffered crushing defeat twice this century. The german armed forces suffered crushing defeat in the last century.
Booktopia has why the germans lose at war, myth of german military superiority by kenneth macksey. As stated in the last video, the german army has a reputation of being vastly superior tactically and operationally to the red army on the eastern front of ww2. German armament miracle, world war ii, albert speer, aircraft industry. However dramatic and spectacular his political career, concentration on hitlers character and personality in some respects bizarre, in others downright mediocre and wholly unpleasant can nevertheless do little to explain the magnetism of his popular appeal. The myth of the clean wehrmacht is the fictitious notion that the regular german armed forces. Criticism by nigel askey of the myth of german superiority on the ww2 eastern front interesting essay by nigel askey regarding german and soviet combat performance in the eastern front in wwii. The myth of german superiority on the ww2 eastern front is misleading, examples of the selected and hence misleading statistics, and why some of the rational used is illfounded. The german army and the russo german war 19411943, by gregory liedtke, 2016. Debunking two american myths information clearing house. Described by prime minister winston churchill as the rafs finest hour, the battle of britain was the first major military campaign in history to be fought entirely in the air. When and how did germany lose air superiority on the. Why the german lose at war the myth of german military superiority. Aug 18, 2017 as stated in the last video, the german army has a reputation of being vastly superior tactically and operationally to the red army on the eastern front of ww2.
727 715 1414 827 1401 489 363 223 114 1124 188 203 816 645 1047 176 838 1105 1535 1041 722 479 1481 174 614 634 1063 1005 943 415 1316 625 114 1413 732 1228 113 775 463 612 874 230 12 1201 507 1193 1228